Does the Law of Attraction Really Work?
Imagining a job offer can help you notice what you want. It cannot make an employer offer you the job. The useful distinction is whether a thought changes something you do: rehearsing an interview answer gives you practice; treating a vivid image as evidence of a future offer does not. The research below looks at that difference.
A practical example
Imagining a job offer can help you notice what you want. It cannot make an employer offer you the job. Rehearsing how you’ll explain a gap in your work history gives you practice answering an awkward question. Picturing the hiring manager calling with good news gives you a pleasant afternoon. Both involve imagination, but only one is rehearsal.
The law of attraction, popularized by The Secret, makes a stronger claim than “your outlook affects what you do.” It says that thoughts draw matching events into your life. There’s no reliable evidence for that claim. It can still feel persuasive: if you pictured the call and then got the job, the coincidence is memorable. What’s missing from that story is how often you pictured a call that never came, or got good news you hadn’t expected at all.
What did the experiments actually test?
In four experiments by Heather Kappes and Gabriele Oettingen (PDF), people who imagined idealized futures showed less energy afterward than participants in the comparison conditions. The researchers measured responses such as changes in blood pressure and how energized people felt. That’s a narrower finding than “optimism is bad.” They weren’t testing whether enjoying a daydream spoils your chances at an interview.
A different line of research pairs a desired outcome with an obstacle and a plan for handling it. A 2021 review of 21 studies found a small to medium average benefit for reaching goals. The authors cautioned that publication bias may make the benefit look larger than it is. The studies evaluated the combined exercise, not the power of a wish in isolation.
Back at the interview, suppose the obstacle is that you rush through the question about the gap and never get to the work you’ve done since. Your plan might be: “If they ask about the gap, I’ll explain it in one sentence, pause, and tell them about the project I finished last month.” Try the answer aloud. You can hear whether you got to the project, even if you’ll never know exactly why the employer chose one candidate over another.
Where the distinction matters most
If the company freezes hiring the next morning, neither a good interview nor an anxious thought caused the freeze. Telling someone they attracted a layoff, an accident, or an illness makes the same mistake under much harder circumstances. Worry isn’t evidence of fault, and you don’t have to replace it with perfect confidence before asking for help.
Keep the part of imagining a better future that you enjoy. If it suggests something worth doing, try it. You can judge a rehearsal by whether you found the words you needed, without treating the next phone call as a verdict on how well you thought.
What the Law of Attraction Claims
The modern version of the idea became popular with the 2006 book and film The Secret. It rests on three assertions: that thoughts are a form of energy, that like energy attracts like energy, and that by controlling your thoughts you can control what happens to you. The first two are statements about physics, and physics does not support them. Thoughts are real in the sense that they shape behavior, but they do not emit a signal that rearranges the world.
The idea is older than the book. In Think and Grow Rich, first published in 1937, Napoleon Hill wrote that “thoughts are things,” but he attached a condition to the line: thoughts are powerful “when they are mixed with definiteness of purpose, persistence, and a burning desire” for their translation into riches or other goals. Read in full, Hill’s point is about sustained effort toward a specific aim, not a promise that wishing will do the work.
Why Imagining Success Is Not Enough
Psychologist Gabriele Oettingen studied what happens when people picture a desired future. In four experiments, positive fantasies about idealized futures were associated with lower energization, which can undermine effort (Kappes and Oettingen, 2011). Positive fantasies can feel like progress, so the energy that should go into the work gets spent on the daydream instead.
A 2021 meta-analysis in Frontiers in Psychology reviewed 21 studies of mental contrasting combined with implementation intentions and found a small-to-medium benefit for goal attainment. The authors noted publication bias, which means the true effect may be smaller than the raw average (Wang, Wang, and Gai’s meta-analysis). The useful part of the approach is not the picture of the outcome. It is the comparison with reality: you imagine the result, then identify the obstacle in your own behavior, then decide what you will do when that obstacle appears.
That method is often called WOOP, short for Wish, Outcome, Obstacle, and Plan. An example looks like this: you wish to run a 5K, you picture finishing it, you name the obstacle, such as getting home late and skipping training, and you make a plan: “If I get home after 6 p.m., then I will run before dinner.” The plan is what changes behavior. The visualization only sets up the problem.