How to Compare Your Offer with Alternatives Fairly

A customer comparing your service with a competitor may have a third option: do the job themselves. Include that option if it’s realistic. A useful comparison makes it easy to see who saves time, who saves money, and where each claim comes from, even if the reader doesn’t choose you.

A practical example

Imagine you run a print shop. You charge $48 for 50 booklets delivered on Friday. A nearby shop quotes $40 for the same print job, with pickup. Can you advertise that your service saves the customer money? Not from those two prices alone.

What the quotes actually tell you

Your quote costs $8 more and includes delivery. A customer already driving past the other shop may prefer pickup. Someone who cannot leave the event venue may gladly pay the difference. Neither choice makes one printer cheaper for everyone. If the buyer only needs guests to see a program, sending a digital copy is another real option; it does not supply printed booklets.

Before publishing a comparison, line up the quantity, page count, paper, finish, deadline, and any mandatory charges. Note when you checked each quote. If you know your own delivery time but not the competitor’s, write “not confirmed” rather than “slower.” Keep the quotes so you can explain the comparison and update it when a price changes.

A claim you could stand behind

“For this 50-booklet job, our quoted price is $48 including delivery. The other quote is $40 with pickup. Choose delivery if the trip is worth more than $8 to you.”

That wording identifies the job and leaves the value of the trip to the reader. In the U.S., the FTC policy on comparative advertising supports truthful, nondeceptive comparisons and calls for clarity about their basis. It does not turn this example into a general claim about either shop. Give the real buyer enough detail to choose the other offer when it suits them better.

Define the decision the reader is making

Start with the buyer’s situation. Which problem are they trying to solve, and what choices could they realistically make? Include more than named competitors: a customer may use an existing tool, do the work themselves, choose a different kind of service, or delay the decision. “Do nothing for now” can be a valid alternative when the cost or inconvenience of switching is greater than the benefit.

Keep the comparison narrow. Comparing every feature of every product can overwhelm the reader and make the page stale. Focus on the few criteria that could change the decision, such as total cost, time to use, required skill, support, or a specific capability.

Choose like-for-like criteria

Use the same criteria for each option. If you compare monthly price, include the same billing period and clarify whether fees, setup, shipping, or add-ons are included. If you compare service speed, define what “fast” means and use comparable conditions. Avoid pairing your strongest feature with a competitor’s weakest feature.

Ask what matters to the buyer rather than what makes your offer look best. A simple worksheet might include:

  • The customer’s must-have requirement.
  • The price and other costs to get the outcome.
  • What is included and what is not.
  • Time, effort, or expertise the customer must contribute.
  • Support, access, or terms that affect the experience.
  • The source and date for each fact.

Leave a criterion blank or label it “not confirmed” when you cannot verify it. A blank is more honest than a guess. When information is missing, ask the provider or omit that comparison rather than assuming the competitor does not offer a feature.

Use evidence you can explain

Prefer current, primary information: published prices, product documentation, service terms, or a direct demonstration under stated conditions. Record when you checked it because offers and terms can change. If you rely on a customer review or a third-party test, explain what it can and cannot show. Do not turn one user’s experience into a general claim about every buyer.

Comparisons in advertising should be clear and truthful. The Federal Trade Commission’s policy statement says truthful comparative advertising can help consumers, while clarity and substantiation matter (FTC: Comparative advertising policy). If you make a claim about a competitor’s product, keep the evidence for that specific claim and describe the conditions of the comparison.

Make the comparison easy to audit. Put the source and date beside each important figure, explain any test conditions, and keep factual specifications separate from your interpretation. If you use a score, explain the scale and why each criterion has that weight. A total score can create false precision when the inputs are estimates or when different buyers value different things.

Show trade-offs, including your own

Explain who each option may suit and where it may fall short. Your offer might cost more but include support; another option might be less expensive but require the customer to do more work. Say so plainly. If your offer is not the right fit for someone with a particular need, state that rather than pushing a sale.

Disclose relationships or incentives that could affect how readers interpret the comparison. If you receive compensation for a recommendation, say so clearly near the relevant links. Do not use words such as “best,” “cheapest,” or “guaranteed” unless you define the claim and can support it. A disclaimer at the end does not fix a misleading headline or an unfair table.